Today's Walk Through the Tombstones is at Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Forest Hill Cemetery is the largest cemetery in Greencastle with nearly 12,000 interments. It is a current cemetery with many new burials. My daughter and I actually originally went out to this cemetery for a specific purpose - to find the grave of Pearl Bryan. She was a late 19th century murder victim that has a lot of paranormal stories attached to her case. I did a separate entry on her grave, life and death. You can check it out
here.
For all of the larger, current cemeteries that we have visited, this has been one of the most interesting. Not only were the graves absolutely beautiful, but there were some very interesting vaults placed in what appeared to be an old riverbed. I would love to go back someday and walk around some more, but for now, let's take a walk through what we found.
~~
Our first stop was just inside the entrance to the cemetery. There is a large open area with this sign:
"In Memory of
the Revolutionary Dead
of Putnam County
Erected by
Washburn Chapter
Daughters of the
American Revolution
1776-1915"
There were no names listed on the backside of the monument, nor were there any other monuments anywhere. I did, however, find a copy of the article from Greencastle dated November 5, 1915, that does list the names of the soldiers honored here. This article in linked
here.
William Edmundson/Edmiston (born in 1750 in Virginia and died in Greencastle, Indiana though the date is unknown; buried in Greencastle City Cemetery)
Isaac Armstrong (born July 1762 near Baltimore Maryland; His death date is unknown, though sometime after 1850 as he is listed in the 1850 census; Same census lists him as being born in Virginia; burial site is unknown)
Jonathan Byrd (born just before 1750 in Virginia; died somewhere around 1827; he was married to Rachel Sweet Byrd and is said to have been buried in the Byrd Family Cemetery on the Old Byrd Farm)
John Buck (born in Hanover, England in 1752 and possible died after November 21, 1836, as this was his last claimed pension payment; it is said that he was taken by Indians during the war and kept prisoner for four months; his burial is unknown)
William Brown (born December 30, 1743, Culpepper County, Virginia; died 1829, Putnamville, Putnam County, Indiana; he and his wife, Elizabeth, were both buried on a small farm, but in 1970, their graves were moved to Putnamville Cemetery)
Nathanial Cunningham (born in Petersburg, Prince George County, Virginia in 1756 or 1768; died on August 16, 1832; he fought in many important battles including Trenton, Princeton, Brandywine, Monmouth, Gates Defeat, and Yorktown; he was buried on a farm east of Greencastle; his dates of enlistment are confusing as one place said 1775, which would make him 7 years old, white another says 1780, which would make him 12 years old; he has a cenotaph here at Forest Hill Cemetery)
Jacob Grider (born September 11, 1763 in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania; died July 23 or 28 1860, Putnam County, Indiana; he was noted to have been in the strongest man in the army)
Lathan/Laban Hall (born 1755 in England; died September 9, 1842 in Putnam County, though it is said that he is buried near Otter Creek in Vigo County)
Thomas Jones (born around 1745; died sometime after 1837 as this was his last collected pension payment; buried on the Burton Farm in Putnam County)
John McHaffle/McHaffie (birth and death date are unknown, though it is said he is buried on the Old McHaffie Homestead, but no one seems to know exactly where this is)
Andrew McPheeters (?) (born in Chester County, Pennsylvania on March 22, 1761; burial date is unknown though he was granted land for his pension in 1834; a date on a memorial stone in Missouri with his grandchildren states that he passed in 1850, but there isn't a burial record for him)
Samuel Moore (born July 14, 1761, Staunton, Virginia; died sometime after 1833; He was married on September 25, 1786 in Greenbrier County, Virginia)
Thomas Rhoten (born around 1755; died January 1852 in Greencastle, Indiana; buried in Beech Grove Cemetery, Putnam County, Indiana)
Abraham Stobaugh (born around 1763 in Montgomery County, Virginia; died in September 1826/1836 and buried on the old Goram Farm)
Thomas Tucker (born February 11, 1757, Halifax County, North Carolina; died 1840; buried in Putnam County, though the cemetery is unnamed)
Robert Whitehead (born 1762, died February 20, 1852, buried near Bainbridge, Indiana, though the name of the cemetery is not listed)
Julius Glazebrook (born April 15, 1752; died September 14, 1847; buried in Carmel Cemetery, near Filmore, Indiana)
William Banks/Ranks (born June 3, 1761, Culpepper County, Virginia; died September 5, 1839; he is said to have been buried in the Old Cemetery in Greencastle, Indiana)
John Barto-/Bartee(?) (birth and death dates are unknown, though it is believed that he passed in February of 1848; it is said that he lived in extreme poverty in a one room log cabin with county assistance; he is buried on the Yates/Yeates Farm, which was near his home)
William Cornwell/Cornell (born February 25, 1762, New York; died November 3, 1850; buried in Bainbridge Cemetery, Bainbridge, Putnam County, Indiana)
Charles Bowen (born September 1749, Virginia; died after 1834 in Putnam County, Indiana; burial isn't known)
Samuel Denny (born August 28, 1755, Chester County, Pennsylvania; died July 4, 1843 at Deer Creek Baptist Church Cemetery)
Silas Hopkins (born in Baltimore, date unknown; death date is unknown, though he is said to be buried in the same cemetery as Abraham Stobaugh which would be on the old Goram Farm)
George Hammer (born May 4, 1762, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; died July 21, 1834 in Putnam County, Indiana; burial is unknown)
Joseph LaFollette, Sr. (born 1773, possibly in France; died sometime in 1834, unsure of location)
William McGaughey (born 1760-1761; died September 4, 1829 and buried in Skillman Cemetery near Russellville, Indiana)
Benjamin Mahoney/Mahorney (born 1760; died December 25, 1854 and buried in Smuthe Cemetery, near Filmore, Indiana)
John Norman (born 1743 in Sussex County, Delaware; died 1833 and buried somewhere in Putnam County, Indiana
Isaiah Slavens (born June 14, 1762, Augusta, County, Indiana; died September 8, 1848 in Putnam County, Indiana; buried in Brick Chapel Cemetery, Putnam County, Indiana)
Peter Stoner (born June 6, 1764; died April 7, 1851; buried in Pleasant Hill Cemetery, Putnam County, Indiana)
John Wolden/Welden/Walden Sr (born March 6, 1756, Middlesex County, Virginia; died December 22, 1835, Putnam County, Indiana; buried in Manhattan Cemetery, Putnam County, Indiana)
John Walles/Walls (born April 4, 1762, York County, Pennsylvania; died 1836; buried in the Old Cemetery in Greencastle, Indiana)
William Denny/Denney (born in Chester County, Pennsylvania, but unsure of the date; died on April 8, 1832; buried in a "private cemetery east of Greencastle", though his headstone is possibly the one that has been found at Stilesville Cemetery in Hendricks County, Indiana)
There are other names listed as being war soldiers in Putnam County, though these are the ones that seem to be connected to this particular monument.
~~~
Our next stop is at the memorial of Joseph Lawson VanCleave.
Born: November 12, 1848
Died: June 22, 1931, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Joseph was the son of Stephen Bennett Van Cleave (1821-1900) and an unnamed mother. Stephen is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery as well, though there is no mention of Joseph's mother.
He had at least one sibling:
Mary Van Cleave Kendall Smith (1854-1934) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He was married to Mary Elizabeth "Lizzie" Critser VanCleave Guss (1851-1938). They were married on July 16, 1869 and were divorced in Decatur County, Indiana on October 1, 1875.
He served in the Civil War in Company F of 123 Indiana Infantry.
~~~
Here we are at the grave of Martin L. Smith.
Born: November 24, 1892
Died: August 26, 1963
He was a Cook in Company H. of the 809th Pioneer Infantry in World War I. The 809th Pioneer Infantry refers to an African American unit that primarily performed construction and labor tasks like building roads and structures in France. They didn't actually see any combat from what I have read, instead mostly performing construction tasks. They were trained in both infantry tactics and combat engineering. The 809th was a segregated unit. There is a wonderful blog post about this unit
here.
Unfortunately, there is no information about his family.
~~~
We now stop at the memorial for Willie E. Sly.
Born: 1896
Died: 1944
Unfortunately, there is no further information for him other that what it states on his stone. He was a Private in the US Army in World War I.
His grave was not mentioned on Find A Grave, so I have added it.
~~~
Here we are at the memorial for Eli Lincoln Smith.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
I believed that he served in the World War II as a Stewards Mate, 2nd Class in the U.S.N.R.. The date November 23, 1945 is shown on the stone. I don't know what this date refers to.
His grave is also not listed on Find A Grave, so I have added this one as well. I did find his name in an Indiana State Summary of War Casualties for the US Navy from 1941-1945, dated 1946.
U.S.N.R. are the United States Navy Reserve.
His parents were Mr. and Mrs. Martin Tony Smith of Greencastle, Indiana.
~~~
This is the grave of John C. Gorham.
Born: June 1845, Putnam County, Indiana
Died: July 26, 1910, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He was the son of Thomas Gorham (1808-1881) and Casandra Hopkins Gorham (1815-1893). They are both buried in Fillmore Cemetery, Fillmore, Putnam County, Indiana.
He had a few siblings:
Alexander Gorham (1835-1914) - buried in Fillmore Cemetery, Fillmore, Putnam County, Indiana
Silas W. Gorham (1839-1865) - buried in Fillmore Cemetery, Fillmore, Putnam County, Indiana (died one month after his brother Thomas, who died in his arms on the train home)
Thomas T. Gorham (1841-1865) - buried in Fillmore Cemetery, Fillmore, Putnam County, Indiana (died on the train ride home in his brother Silas' arms)
Sally Ann Gorham (1884-1915) - buried in Fillmore Cemetery, Fillmore, Putnam County, Indiana
He was married to Mary Alice McCammack Gorham (1861-1921). She is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana, likely near him, though at this time there is no photo of her headstone. They were married in 1879.
They had several children:
Effa "Effie" Esther Gorham Parrish (1873-1943) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Emma Jane Gorham Garl (1882-1957) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Lida "Lydia" M. Gorham Tobin (1883-1964) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Harvey "Horsey" Edward Gorham (1888-1972) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Earl Gorham (1899-1976) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He served in the Civil War in Company E of the 1st Indiana Heavy Artillery.
~~~
This is the grave of James Thomburgh.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
He served in the Civil War in Company H of the 43rd Indiana Infantry.
The only mention of a James Thomburgh is a Private who enlisted in Company D of the 31st Indiana Infantry on September 20, 1861 but deserted just before he was set to show up. The 31st Indiana Infantry was mustered in Terre Haute, Indiana.
I have found mentioned of a James Thornburg and there are Thornburg's buried in Forest Hill Cemetery.
His grave was not listed on Find A Grave, so I have added it.
~~~
We now come to the grave of Daniel Benedict Rowland.
Born August 18, 1835, Tompkins County, New York
Died: January 16, 1907, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
I haven't found the names of his parents or any siblings.
He was married twice, his first wife being Anna M. Moon Rowland (1836-1908). They were married on January 19, 1856 in Pine River, Gratiot, Michigan, but according to an affidavit for his Civil War pension, he told her that he was going on a hunting trip in February of 1877. When he didn't return, she assumed that he was dead. Instead, he had run off with another woman with whom he'd had a child with. This date of 1877, doesn't line up with the date of marriage of his second wife, listed below.
They had a few children that I found:
Mary Jane Rowland Pierce (1856-1944) - buried in Greenwood Cemetery, Hadley, Lapeer County, Michigan
John Smith Rowland (1859-1942) - buried in Riverside Cemetery, Saint Charles, Saginaw County, Michigan (neither he nor his wife has a headstone)
Milicent "Melissa" Rowland Williams (1866-1930) - buried in Woodlawn Memorial Cemetery, Clio, Genesee County, Michigan
Gladness Emma Rowland Soule (1869-1899) - buried in Riverside Cemetery, Vassar, Tuscola County, Michigan
Her name was Rena Palmer Rowland (1840-1911). They are listed as having been married in 1876. I can't find any mention of this child that he supposedly had with her. She is, however, buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Indiana.
Daniel's obituary published in the Star and Democrat on January 20, 1907 is filled with mistakes. This obituary states that he was a native of Wisconsin, was a member of the Iron Brigade of General Bragg and had two sons when he died. You can find out more about the Iron Brigade
here.
Daniel was not a native of Wisconsin, never served in the Iron Brigade and I only found one son. Instead, he served in Company D of the 26th Michigan Infantry. He was wounded in action on May 18, 1864 and was discharged the following day.
According to a report in the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette on December 22, 1900 that he was convicted of running an illegal saloon in Greencastle, Indiana.
~~~
We now stop at the cenotaph for Nathaniel Cunningham.
Born: 1754, Prince George County, Virginia
Died: August 16, 1832, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
His obituary, published in the Indiana Journal on August 20, 1832, states that he entered the Northern Army under General George Washington. He fought in several of the notable battles including Trenton, Princeton, Brandywine, Monmouth, Gates Defeat, and Yorktown. He was buried on his own land and his headstone was moved to Forest Hill, though I only found this memorial stone. His memorial stone notes that he was a Sergeant in the First Virginia Regiment of the Revolutionary War.
He was married to Elizabeth Sneed Cunnigham (?-?). They were married in Caswell County, North Carolina on September 24, 1790.
He had several children:
Alexander Cunningham (?-?) - burial unknown
Sarah "Sally" Michaux Cunnigham Bulla (1798-1882) - buried in Bulla Family Cemetery, Asheboro, Randolph County, North Carolina
Amelia Cunningham (1794-1859) - buried in Bloomfield South Cemetery, Bloomfield, Davis County, Iowa
Elizabeth Cunningham Brown (1797-1866) - buried in Fillmore Cemetery, Fillmore, Putnam County, Indiana (she does not have a headstone)
John W. Cunningham (1800-1882) - buried in Baldwin Cemetery, Mahaska County, Iowa
Susanna Cunningham (?-?) - burial unknown
Benjamin Cunningham (?-?) - burial unknown
Lucinda Cunningham (?-?) - burial unknown
~~~
This is the grave of James R. Blakely.
Born: 1838, North Carolina
Died: February 14, 1903, Putnam County, Indiana
I have no information for his parents of any siblings.
He was married to Amadora Belle Lewis Blakely (1863-1945) in 1880. She is buried in an unmarked grave in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana. She passed away at the Soldiers home in Lafayette after a prolonged illness.
They had a couple of children:
Henry Frederick Blakely (1860-1931) - buried in Washington Park East Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Josephine Blakely Piffer (1883-1951) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (her grave is unmarked)
He served in Company K of the 1st Indiana Heavy Artillery.
~~~
We now stop at a large memorial for Civil War Soldiers. This is the first side.
First is listed William F. Boyd.
Born: unknown
Died: September 12, 1864, Andersonville, Sumter County, Georgia
He was a soldier in the Union Army serving in Company F or the 123rd Indiana Infantry. He died while being held at the Andersonville Prison, a Confederate Prisoner of War camp. It has been noted that he was starved to death.
Next is John W. Busby.
Born: November 4, 1830, Union County, Indiana
Died: May 4, 1865, La Grange, Fayette County, Tennessee
He has a memorial stone nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery, though I am not sure if he is actually buried here.
He was a 1st Lieutenant in Company D of the 9th Indiana Infantry.
The third name listed on the monument is William Conklin.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
He was a Sergeant in Company I of the 159th Indiana Infantry in the Spanish American War.
The fourth name listed in J.H. McGill.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
I have no information about him.
The final name on the plaque is J. Singer.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
I have no information about him.
~~~
The next side has many more names on it.
First is R.T McCorkle.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
I can not find an R.T. McCorkle, but there is a T. McCorkle in this cemetery. I am not sure if they are the same person or not.
Next is H.A. Moyers, C.A. Newman, T. Olds, B. Olmacht, H. Overman, J.T. Overman, R.E. Overton, J.J. Palmer, J.W. Patrick, W. Phipps, G.H. Pottorff, R.A. Proctor, C.R. Rawlins, T.J. Riddle, A.J. Robinson, J.M. Sexton, J.T. Sheets, S.T. Smith, P. Sowder, D. Stewart, S.M. Stigleman, W.T. Thurman, J.H. Tincher, J.F. Whipley, A.J. Wilson, C.E. Wishmere, N. Wright, and P. Young.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
T. Talbott
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
There is a Thomas Talbott buried here that fits in the timeframe for the Civil War, but there is no information for his service, so I am not sure that this is the right entry.
J.P. White
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
There is a John White buried here that fits into the right time period, but he doesn't have a headstone photo or any information for service. I don't know if this is the right person or not.
I am not sure if any of these names are listed in other cemeteries or not, but they have no inforamtion connected to Forest Hill Cemetery.
~~~
Born May 2, 1892
Died: January 20, 1944
He was the son of William Turner Parrish (1871-1953) and his first wife, Naomi M. Jones Mills (?-1954). He is buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery, while she is buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana with what must be her second husband.
He had several siblings:
Walter Lee Parrish (1902-1982) - buried in West Ridge Park Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Nellie Mae Parrish Bailey (1903-1962) - buried in New Union Cemetery, Spencer, Owen County, Indiana
Robert Joseph Parrish (1908-1981) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Harry Albert Parrish (1910-1986) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Arthur Grove Parrish (1914-1992) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Guy Estal Parrish (1906-1991) - buried in Cloverdale Cemetery, Cloverdale, Putnam County, Indiana
Earl Glendon "Ginnie" Parrish (1920-1964) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He served in World War I as a Private First Class 302 Guard & Fire Company QMC. I believe that the Guard and Fire Company may be a group of firefighters, but I have found no information at this time to confirm that.
~~~
Here we are now at the grave of Moses C. Vanlandingham.
Born: January 17, 1844
Died: April 9, 1918
His father was Oliver Vanlandingham (1812-1893) and Phoebe Ann Bagley Vanlandingham (1812-1894). He is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery as well and is listed as having served in the Civil War on Company K of the 123rd Indiana Infantry. I am not sure where Phoebe is buried.
He had several siblings:
James M. Vanlandingham (1841-1864) - burial unknown
Sarah Louise Vanlandingham (1842-?) - burial unknown
Margaret E. Vanlandingham (1846-1880) - burial unknown
Armilda Van Landingham (1850-1882) - burial unknown
Catherine Vanlangingham (1853-?) - burial unknown
Elizabeth E. Vanlandingham (1856-1862) - buried in Greencastle City Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Caty Vanlandingham (1864-?) - burial unknown
Charles Vanlandingham (1866-?) - burial unknown
He married to Mary Josephine "Josie" Douglass Vanlandingham (1867-1923). They were married on June 18, 1891. She is buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery.
They had several children:
David "Davie" Vanlandingham (1894-1950) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (served in World War I in the Evac Hospital 34)
Elizabeth May Vanlandingham Taylor (1896-1938) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Hazel J. Vanlandingham (1904-?) - burial unknown
He was a Civil War Veteran, serving in Company F of the 123rd Indiana Infantry.
~~~
We now come to the grave of James C. Moran.
Born: 1839
Died: November 8, 1916
He served in Civil War in Company I of the 115th Indiana Infantry. Unfortunately, I have no further information about him.
~~~
Here we are at the grave of George W. Snider.
Born: 1842
Died: April 12, 1915
I have no information for his parents or any siblings.
He was married to Leonia "Lena" Castello Snider (1851-1948). She is buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery with her son, Evan.
They had a few children:
Lillian Catherine Snider Tirey (1871-1907) - buried in Green Hill Cemetery, Bedford, Lawrence County, Indiana
Noble L. Snider/Snyder (1874-1960) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Shirley Snyder Terrell (1881-1916) - buried in Mitchell City Cemetery, Mitchell, Lawrence County, Indiana
Evan Snider (1886-1971) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He served in the Civil War in Company A of the 137th Indiana Infantry.
~~~
This is the grave of Joseph C. Wells.
Born: 1835, Ohio
Died: February 15, 1915, Putnam County, Indiana
He was the son of Joseph Wells (?-?) and Mary Bishop Wells (?-?). It is possible that his father's name is James Wells as I found a James Wells married to Mary Ellen Bishop Wells, both buried in Forest Hill Cemetery. But, at this time, I don't have any confirmation.
He served in the Civil War in Company I of the 55th Indiana Infantry.
~~~
Here we are at the grave of James Deal.
Born: February 25, 1845, Putnam County, Indiana
Died: September 29, 1914, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
He was the son of Andrew Deal (?-?) and Mary Barnett Deal (?-?). I have no information about them or any siblings.
He enlisted as a Private on September 6, 1864 in Company H 48th Indiana Volunteer Infantry. He was involved in General Sherman's march to the sea from November to December 1864 as well as the Battle of Bentonville in March 1865. He mustered out a couple of months later.
He was married three times. His first wife being Malinda J. Watts Deal (1853-1873). They were married in Spencer, Owen County, Indiana on April 16, 1871. They did not have any children.
His second wife was Lucinda Medaris Deal Stout (1852-1927). They were married on July 20, 1874 in Spencer, Owen County, Indiana. They never divorced, but she did leave him and move to Iowa where she remarried at least two more times. For some reason his pension notes claim that she was "supposed to have died".
They had two children, though I only have the name of one:
Thomas Wesley Deal (1875-1946) - buried in Riverview Cemetery, Louisville, Cass County, Nebraska
His third wife was Rebecca Jane Minor Laswell Deal (1838-1921). They were married on April 26, 1884 in Spencer, Owen County, Indiana. They separated in 1901, though further information states that in April 1901 he deserted her. There is concern about this marriage since there was no evidence that he had divorced his second wife, nor had she died, and Rebecca did not divorce her second husband, Thomas.
James died at the Central Indiana Hospital for the Insane in Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana.
~~~
This is the grave of James N. Robinson.
Born: unknown
Died: unknown
His headstone states
"MUSN
CO E
24 US INF"
The 24th US Infantry was a unit of the US Army active from 1869 to 1951 and was primarily made up of African American soldiers. This unit was considered one of the Buffalo Soldier regiments, which were brought about to guard the frontier. These troops, many veterans of the US Colored Troops were ordered to garrison frontier posts in the Western US, fighting the Native Americans, protecting roadways against bandits and guarding the US-Mexico border.
I am not sure what MUSN stands for.
~~~
We now come to the grave of Hamilton Gray/Grey.
Born: October 6, 1819, Tennessee
Died: August 2, 1909
His mother was Polly Grey (?-?). She was born in Tennessee. Unfortunately, the name of his father is not listed on his death certificate. I have no idea where she is buried.
I believe that his wife's name was Lucinda Gray (?-?). Unfortunately, I am not sure if this is correct or not, nor am I able to find her burial site.
He is listed as having a child:
Anna Gray Kelly (1858-1925) - buried in Woodlawn Cemetery, Terre Haute, Vigo County, Indiana.
~~~
This is a burial marker for Willard Vandergriff
Born: 1822
Died: 1892
His memorial was not listed on the Forest Hill page on Find A Grave, so I have added it. Unfortunately, I couldn't find any information about him and there are no other Vandergriffs buried in Forest Hill. His marker was in the Veteran's section, so I believe that he may be a Civil War Veteran. I will have to comb through some documents to see what I can find.
~~~
This is the grave of Absalom H. Scott.
Born: July 14, 1810
Died: December 4, 1892
He was married to Louisa N. Weatherford Scott (1822-1910). She is buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery.
They had a few children:
Susan G. Scott (1841-1876) - buried in Dunlap Cemetery, Dennison, Clark County, Illinois
Elizabeth Seymour Scott Dewitt (1848-1938) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Henry F. Scott (1868-1877) - buried in Dunlap Cemetery, Dennison, Clark County, Illinois
~~~
Here we are at the grave of Letha E. Talbott Squier.
Born: April 15, 1837
Died: June 4, 1916
She is the daughter of Dr. William E. Talbott (1801-1852) and Nancy Talbott (1800-1884). They are both buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery.
She was married to A.T. Squier (1832-1915) in 1857. He is buried near her in Forest Hill Cemetery.
~~~
We now come to the grave of Nancy Talbott.
Born: July 15, 1800
Died: August 12, 1884
She was the daughter of Reverend Edward Talbott (1764-1854) and Elizabeth Standiford Talbott (1763-1841). They are both buried in Forest Hill Cemetery nearby.
She had several siblings:
William Talbott (1784-1872) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
David Standiford Talbott (1786-1867) - buried in Oak Ridge Cemetery, Springfield, Sanamon County, Illinois (there is a note that his grave and that of his wife, Harriet, were moved from Gardner Township Cemetery)
Edward Talbott (?-?) - burial unknown
John S. Talbott (?-?) - burial unknown (opened the first grocery store in New Maysville in 1832 and was also postmaster in 1834)
Othniel/Othneal/Orthaniel Talbott (1795-1847) - his burial is marked as unknown (it is possible that he owned land that the town of New Maysville was platted on
Luther Jarrett Talbott (?-?) - burial unknown
Nancy Talbott Talbott (?-?) - burial unknown
Benjamin Talbott (?-?) - burial unknown
Lorenzo "Tolbert" Talbott (1803-1834) - buried in New Maysville Cemetery, New Maysville, Putnam County, Indiana
Aquilla Standiford Talbott (1805-1854) - buried in Linn Grove Cemetery, Mediapolis, Des Moines County, Iowa (it is possible that he is actually buried in Greencastle somewhere and that his monument in Linn Grove Cemetery is a cenotaph)
Thomas Asbury Talbott (1808-1884) - buried in Greencastle City Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
She was married to Dr. William E. Talbott (1801-1854). They were married in 1822. He is buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana.
They had at least one child:
Letha E. Squier (1837-1916) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
~~~
Our next stop is at the Crouch Family Monument, with the first name being that of Samuel Jerome Crouch.
Born: 1823
Died: 1869
He was the son of Nathan Crouch (1798-1865) and Sarah Seaton Crouch (1797-1869). They are both buried in Wesley Chapel Cemetery in Putnam County, Indiana.
He had one sibling that I have found:
Margaret C. Crouch Elwell (1832-1906) - buried in Mount Vernon Cemetery, Atchison, Atchison County, Kansas (she is listed as having died from liver cancer)
He was married to Sarah Jane Fulton Crouch on August 29, 1846, who name is listed just below his.
Born: 1823, Indiana
Died: May 16, 1893, Putnam County, Indiana
She was the daughter of Elisha Wyncoop Fulton (1793-1866) and Elizabeth Evans Fulton (1790-1869). They are both buried in Locust Grove Methodist Episcopal Cemetery, Locust Grove, Wayne County, Indiana.
She had a few siblings:
Robert Townsend Fulton (1818-1887) - buried in Doddridge Chapel Cemetery, Centerville, Wayne County, Indiana
Doctor Richard Evans Fulton (1818-1893) - buried in Oak Hill Cemetery, Taylorville, Christian County, Illinois
Elisha T. Fulton (1824-1854) - buried in Locust Grove Methodist Episcopal Cemetery, Locust Grove, Wayne County, Indiana.
Martha E. Fulton (1831-1848) - buried in Locust Grove Methodist Episcopal Cemetery, Locust Grove, Wayne County, Indiana.
They had a few children, two of which are buried with them and listed on the headstone:
Sarah C. Crouch (1848-1927) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (name is listed as Sarah Elizabeth Seaton on the headstone, but the death dates match)
Martha Emily Ellen Crouch (1851-1941) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (name is listed on the headstone)
Richard H. Crouch (1855-1920) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Mary Francis Crouch Cheek (1860-1945) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
~~~
This is the grave of Mattie B. Goodbar.
Born: September 8, 1862
Died: August 21, 1864
She was the young daughter of Albert L. Goodbar (1838-1911) and Ann Eliza Goodbar (1840-1897). She is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery nearby, but he is buried in Maple Ridge Cemetery, Waveland, Montgomery County, Indiana.
She had one sibling:
Lawrence H. Goodbar (1861-1916) - buried in Mount Olivert Cemetery, Fort Worth, Tarrant County, Texas
~~~
We now stop at the grave of Andrew Malone Lockridge.
Born: March 30, 1814, Mount Sterling, Montgomery County, Kentucky
Died: November 2, 1893, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He was the son of Robert Lockridge (1784-1826) and Elizabeth L. Meloan/Malone Lockridge (1786-1869). They are also buried in Forest Hill Cemetery and their names are listed on the back of the monument, though it is possible that he is actually buried elsewhere.
He had many siblings:
Margaret Lockridge Black (1811-1863) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Rachel Ozier Lockridge Bridges (1812-1881) - buried in Brick Chapel Cemetery, Brick Chapel, Putnam County, Indiana
Louisa E. Lockridge Goodbar (1816-1886) - buried in Ladoga Cemetery, Ladoga, Montgomery County, Indiana
Permelia Lockridge O'Hair (1818-1856) - buried in Brick Chapel Cemetery, Brick Chapel, Putnam County, Indiana
Virginia Lockridge (1820-1895) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Elizabeth Ann Lockridge Farrow (1822-1903) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Dulcenia Lockridge Ashby (1825-1915) - buried in Ladoga Cemetery, Ladoga, Montgomery County, Indiana
Robert Zilifro Lockridge (1827-1899) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
He was married to Elizabeth Shore Farrow Lockridge in 1843, whose name is listed below his:
Born: November 24, 1826, Mount Sterling, Montgomery County, Kentucky
Died: February 4, 1888
She was the daughter of Colonel Alexander Shores Farrow (1794-1877) and Elizabeth Nelson Farrow (1791-1863). They are both buried in Colonel Alexander Farrow Family Cemetery, Morton, Putnam County, Indiana
She had many siblings:
William Simpson Farrow, Sr. (1816-1863) - buried in Colonel Alexander Farrow Family Cemetery, Morton, Putnam County, Indiana
James R. Farrow (1818-1887) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
David Parker Farrow (1819-1906) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Doctor Alexander Cummins Farrow (1821-1894) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Francis Marion Farrow (1825-1858) - buried in Colonel Alexander Farrow Family Cemetery, Morton, Putnam County, Indiana
Mary Quincy Farrow Crow (1829-1918) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Susan Jane Farrow Bryan (1833-1913) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (she was the mother of Pearl Bryan, murder victim, who is buried nearby)
Andrew and Elizabeth had a few children:
Robert A. Lockridge (1844-1846) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (name is listed at the bottom of the headstone)
Simpson Farrow Lockridge (1846-1928) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (he served in the Civil War in Company F 133rd Indiana Volunteer Infantry)
Alexander Howard Lockridge (1848-1921) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (he served in the Civil War in Company F 133rd Indiana Volunteer Infantry)
Albert Owen Lockridge (1851-1923) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
~~~
We now come to the grave of Pearl Bryan.
Born: October 25, 1872, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Died: January 31, 1896, Fort Thomas, Campbell County, Kentucky
She was the daughter of Alexander Stanford Bryan (1824-1901) and Susan Jane Farrow Bryan (1833-1913). They are both buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery.
She had many siblings:
Frances Isabelle "Belle" Bryan Yates (1850-1899) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (according to an article in the Topeka Daily Capital dated March 15, 1899, she was nearly crushed to death by a folding bed, just days after she was granted a divorce from her husband)
James Parker Bryan (1852-1933) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Elizabeth Bryan Hamrick (1855-1948) - buried in Boone Hutcheson Cemetery, Reelsville, Putnam County, Indiana
Elvira "Ella" Simpson Bryan Kellar (1856-1943) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Flora Bryan Mitchell (1859-1881) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Marion Bryan (1861-1882) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Mary B. Bryan Stanley (1863-1939) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Wheat Ridge, Jefferson County, Colorado
Auta Bryan Harris (1865-1891) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Jennie Bryan (1870-1895) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
It is said that she had been pregnant at the time of her death, so there is also a listing for an Infant Bryan with no information.
I have done a longer entry on my blog for Pearl with information about her death, which you can read
here.
~~~
This is the grave of Flora Bryan Mitchell.
Born: February 16, 1859
Died: February 28, 1881
She was the daughter of Alexander Stanford Bryan (1824-1901) and Susan Jane Farrow Bryan (1833-1913). They are both buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery.
She had many siblings:
Frances Isabelle "Belle" Bryan Yates (1850-1899) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana (according to an article in the Topeka Daily Capital dated March 15, 1899, she was nearly crushed to death by a folding bed, just days after she was granted a divorce from her husband)
James Parker Bryan (1852-1933) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Elizabeth Bryan Hamrick (1855-1948) - buried in Boone Hutcheson Cemetery, Reelsville, Putnam County, Indiana
Elvira "Ella" Simpson Bryan Kellar (1856-1943) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Marion Bryan (1861-1882) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Mary B. Bryan Stanley (1863-1939) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Wheat Ridge, Jefferson County, Colorado
Auta Bryan Harris (1865-1891) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Jennie Bryan (1870-1895) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Pearl Bryan (1872-1896) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
She was married to Charles J. Mitchell (1857-1920) in 1879. He is buried in New South Park Cemetery, Martinsville, Morgan County, Indiana.
~~~
Here is the grave of Caroline "Carrie" Allie Friend Allen.
Born: August 9, 1873, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Died: April 30, 1958, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
She was the daughter of Joseph Friend (1840-1915) and Earnestina Bodemer Friend (1837-1903). They are both buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery and are listed as being natives of Baden, Germany. They were married in 1868.
She had one sibling that I have found:
Kathryn Magdaline Friend Johns (1870-1949) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Putnam County, Indiana
She was married twice, first to Albert "Bert" A. Ruark (1875-1912) on June 12, 1901. He is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Putnam County, Indiana, though in the mausoleum.
Her second husband was Doctor Charles Austin Allen (1842-1923). They were married on March 28, 1916. He was a Civil War Veteran having served in Company B of the 2nd Detachment of the Columbia Infantry. He served three months, then reenlisted for three years, which ended up being partly in the Navy. He is buried next to her in Forest Hill Cemetery.
~~~
Next we take a stop at the two family vaults that are located within a small stream valley. These are very interesting as I have never come across anything like this in a cemetery. These two vaults - Goulding and Overstreet - are situated just down from a stone arched bridge. It is clear that when it rains, this area is filled with water, which would be getting into these vaults. It seems so odd.
First is the Goulding family vault. It is gated with an an iron gate and has four burials inside of it.
First is that of Elizabeth "Lizzie" H. Goulding.
Born: February 29, 1864
Died: July 12, 1930
Next to her is Myra Ada Goulding
Born: August 7, 1852
Died: March 1, 1929
Their parents were William Onslow Goulding (1830-1902) and Charlotte Adeline Day Goulding (1834-1892), both of whom are buried in the vault.
Below them is Charlotte Adeline Day Goulding
Born: January 26, 1834
Died: February 14, 1892
She was the daughter of Samuel Day (1795-1851) and Rhoda Louisa Hyde Day (1802-1843). They are both buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Salem, Washington County, Indiana.
She had a couple of siblings:
Warren Day (1829-1916) - buried in Lucas Cemetery Lucas, Russell County, Kansas
John Oliver Day (1831-1907) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Salem, Washington County, Indiana
And finally is that of William Onslow Goulding
Born: April 17, 1830
Died: December 27, 1902
His mother was Adah Jewett Goulding Boutelle (1808-1885) and father was William Goulding (?-?). They were married on September 12, 1828 in Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts. She is buried in Evergreen Cemetery, Worcester County, Massachusetts. I am not sure where he is buried.
William had at least one sibling:
James Payson Boutelle (1850-1850) - buried in Evergreen Cemetery, Worcester County, Massachusetts
William and Lizzie also had one other child who is not buried in the vault:
Mary Adeline Goulding Evans (1856-1935) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
As an interesting note, according to the paperwork for Forest Hill's induction as a National Historic Site, the Goulding family were partners with another group in operating a planning mill that produced doors, sashes, venetian and panel shutters and windows and door frames from the mid 1850s into the early 1900's.
~~~
Next to it, is the Overstreet Vault. It is dated 1887, but it is sealed. Unfortunately, all of the Overstreet entries on Find A Grave are not for this vault, so I am not sure who is buried here. It is a beautiful monument located just next to the Goulding vault.
The National Historic Site paperwork notes that the Overstreet's produced many dentists in their family and speaks of an Orsa Overstreet, who was cremated. The location of his ashes is marked as unknown, though he was cremated at Washington Park Crematory in Indianapolis, so he may have been interred in Washington Park East Cemetery. This is just speculation.
~~~
We now come to the grave of Richard McMannis.
Born: August 1, 1826, Ireland
Died: November 9, 1889
He was married to Brigad O'Boyle McMannis, whose name is listed beneath his on the stone.
Born: December 18, 1829, County Donegal, Ireland
Died: January 19, 1911
They had a few children:
John McMannis (1854-1885) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Mary McMannis Donaghue (1856-1931) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Mackey McMannis (1857-1889) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Maggie McMannis (1861-1885) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Hannah McMannis O'Connell (1863-1950) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
~~~
Here is the grave of John W. Robe.
Born: August 21, 1843
Died: March 30, 1937
He was the son of
William Henry Robe (1816-1863) and
Nancy St. John Robe (1818-1886). He is buried in Greenlawn Cemetery, Franklin, Johnson County, Indiana, while she is buried in Spring Creek Chapel Cemetery, La Porte City, Black Hawk County, Iowa William was the victim of a random act of violence in 1863. He was murdered on his farm in Morgan County, Indiana on May 21, 1863, shot while in a pasture by a Union Army deserter named Sylvester Bailey. This murder was said to have been instigated by the Knights of the Golden Circle, a secret society that was founded in 1854 by George W.L. Bickley. The object of this society was to create a new country called Golden Circle where slavery would have been legal. You can read more about it
here.
.
He had a few siblings:
William M. Robe (1853-1942) - buried in Forest Lawn Memorial Park, Long Beach, Los Angeles, California.
Charles F. Robe (1856-1941) - buried in Evergreen Cemetery, Vinton, Benton County, Iowa
Emma Marie Robe Lizer (1863-1934) - buried in Patton Cemetery, Anderson County, Kansas
He was married to Sarah M. Stevenson Robe in 1870, whose name is listed below his. She was his first wife.
Born: September 22, 1846
Died: October 27, 1914
She was the daughter of Doctor Alexander Campbell Stevenson (1802-1889) and Mary Jane Gillespie Stevenson (1819-1848). They are both buried nearby in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana.
She had many siblings:
Catherine C. Stevenson (1839-1844) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Margaret J. Stevenson (1841-1844) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Mary Nelson Stevenson Bridges (1844-1918) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
Margaret E. Stevenson (1836-1837) - buried in Forest Hill Cemetery, Greencastle, Putnam County, Indiana
James Stevenson (1851-1930) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Joanna Campbell Stevenson Cline (1853-1935) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Frances Jane Stevenson Benton (1855-1939) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Henry Foster Stevenson (1858-1918) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Elizabeth Stevenson (1860-1925) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Margaret Stevenson (1862-1942) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Benjamin Cox Stevenson (1864-1952) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
Harriet D. Stevenson Pinney (1865-1930) - buried in Rosedale Cemetery, Montclair, Essex County, New Jersey
Susan Edith Stevenson (1870-1935) - buried in Crown Hill Cemetery, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
The other side of the Robe Monument is a cenotaph for James T. Robe.
Born: May 6, 1841
Died: June 7, 1865
He is buried in the National Cemetery in Chattanooga, Tennessee. Unfortunately, there is no information on his service or how he died.
~~~
This vault is marked as "F.H.C. 1880" and is a magnificent structure right at the entrance of the cemetery. Unfortunately, however, it is not recorded anywhere that I can find as to who "F.H.C.". What I did find, however, is, once again, from the National Historic Site documents. It is noted that this vault, or crypt as they call it, was used, basically, as a receiving vault. It was used to hold the remains for many years until that went out of use. Probably because they would have been held at a funeral home or some such until time for burial. Now it is used for equipment. It is sad that it is unknown as to who this vault belonged to.
~~~
Our final stop is at the grave of Fred A. Peyton.
Born: 1867
Died: January 23, 1927
He served in the Spanish American War in Company 1 of the 159th Indiana Infantry.
I haven't got any information about his family.
~~~
I hope that you have enjoyed your Walk Through Forest Hill Cemetery in Greencastle, Indiana. You can see more about it
here.